This week, I stopped being a snob long enough to try a pie crust recipe from the book.  Every time we have made a pie for the group, I have always stuck with what I know.  I was starting to feel like a poor sport for not stepping out of my comfort zone and trying a new recipe.  I even did all the steps like I was supposed to.  I made the dough, the refrigerated it, then I froze it and then I froze some more of it....and I liked it.
But the question is; is this pie crust better than the one I normally use? Apparently butter is better than shortening? (Yes, that's a question) But is 1 cup of butter better than 2/3 cup of shortening? I really don't know. The Betty Crocker recipe that I normally use is so easy that sometimes when I am making a pie, I don't even refrigerate the dough if I'm in a hurry. This one seemed so temperamental. I guess what I am saying is that I still love the recipe I have always used. I like not having to freeze the dough before trying to shape it and the ease of it. Having said that, if I were avoiding shortening at all costs, this recipe would be a go-to. It was flaky and buttery and delicious.
But the question is; is this pie crust better than the one I normally use? Apparently butter is better than shortening? (Yes, that's a question) But is 1 cup of butter better than 2/3 cup of shortening? I really don't know. The Betty Crocker recipe that I normally use is so easy that sometimes when I am making a pie, I don't even refrigerate the dough if I'm in a hurry. This one seemed so temperamental. I guess what I am saying is that I still love the recipe I have always used. I like not having to freeze the dough before trying to shape it and the ease of it. Having said that, if I were avoiding shortening at all costs, this recipe would be a go-to. It was flaky and buttery and delicious.
The pie was lovely.  I think I must have had some juicy peaches and could have benefited from an extra 1/2 T or so of cornstarch.  My filling was a little more runny than I would have liked, but it still tasted so good.  I don't really think of myself as the kind of person who likes pie, but throw a scoop of ice cream on some warm pie and mmmmm.  I just really don't know myself at all.
This was a great recipe and a great pick!  If you'd like the recipe you can find it on Talesha's blog HERE.  Thanks for a great pick Talesha!


I'm not a pie person at all, but this looks really good today!!
ReplyDeleteWhat a trooper you are!
ReplyDeletelove pie and yours looks delicious!
ReplyDeleteCarmen
How pretty! Your lattice top looks impressive.
ReplyDelete